When Your Body Shop and Insurance Company Disagree, Who Pays?
You've been in a minor accident, and your car needs some repairs. You file an insurance claim, take the vehicle to a body shop, and expect the process to be fairly straightforward. Then the shop calls with some unexpected news. Your insurance company has approved $2,800 in repairs, but the shop estimates the work will cost $4,100. That's a $1,300 difference, and you're wondering who's going to pay it.
Disagreements between insurance companies and body shops, though not frequent, happen for several reasons: differences in labor rates, questions about which repairs are necessary, parts being used, and recalibration needs. Sometimes the difference is resolved with a revised estimate, while other times the two parties have different opinions about how the vehicle should be repaired. Understanding why these disagreements occur, and what rights you have as a Virginia driver, can help you avoid delays and unexpected expenses.
Why repair estimates don't always match
An insurance adjuster's initial estimate is based on the damage identified during the first inspection, but some damage isn't visible until the body shop begins taking the vehicle apart. Suppose you've been rear-ended and the insurance company approves $2,800 to repair your bumper and trunk lid.
Once the shop removes the bumper, it discovers damage to the reinforcement structure underneath, bringing the estimate to $4,100. The shop submits a supplemental estimate documenting the additional damage, which the insurer reviews to determine whether the added repairs are covered and how much it will pay. This is a normal part of the claims process, and a revised estimate doesn't necessarily mean the insurance company and body shop disagree.
Modern vehicle technology has made estimating repairs more complicated. Bumpers, windshields, and other components often contain cameras, sensors, and electronics that require inspection or recalibration after an accident. According to a 2025 report from CCC Intelligent Solutions, a company that provides technology to the auto insurance and repair industries, more than half of the safety-system calibrations recorded in participating insurer repair networks during the first quarter of 2025 appeared on supplemental estimates rather than the original estimates. In other words, the need for some of this work wasn't identified until later in the repair process.
Labor rates also differ between repair facilities, particularly when specialized training or equipment is needed. Parts availability can affect costs, and a shop may recommend replacing a damaged component that an insurance adjuster believes can be repaired. While many of these differences are resolved through documentation and further review, some involve genuine disagreements about what work is necessary.
When the disagreement involves how your car should be repaired
Imagine your vehicle has been damaged in a front-end collision. The body shop recommends replacing a component and recalibrating the forward collision-warning system, following the manufacturer's repair instructions. The insurance adjuster questions whether the additional procedure is necessary and requests more information before approving it. Unlike the earlier example, where hidden damage increased the estimate, this disagreement involves how the vehicle should be repaired.
The shop may provide manufacturer instructions supporting its recommendation, while the insurer may arrange another inspection to evaluate the proposed work. Virginia law allows supplemental repair estimates to be prepared using photographs or digital images, but when repairs are disputed, a personal inspection is required. If the shop and insurer still cannot agree, the vehicle owner may face a difficult decision, particularly if the shop refuses to complete the repairs for the approved amount.
Fortunately, Virginia drivers have some important protections. State law prohibits insurance companies from requiring you to use a particular repair facility as a condition of settling a claim. Many insurers recommend shops with which they have established relationships, and these facilities often communicate directly with adjusters and may offer repair guarantees. You're free to choose another shop, but there's an important limitation: your right to choose a repair facility doesn't mean your insurer must pay whatever that shop charges.
Virginia law doesn't require insurers to pay more than the prevailing competitive charges for equivalent repairs in the surrounding area, so choosing a shop with substantially higher labor rates may leave you responsible for the difference.
Your right to choose a repair shop doesn't mean your insurer must pay whatever that shop charges. |
Does it matter which replacement parts are used?
Another source of disagreement involves original manufacturer parts versus aftermarket replacements. Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts are made by or for your vehicle's manufacturer, while aftermarket parts are produced by other companies. Recycled parts generally come from previously used vehicles. Virginia permits insurers to use replacement parts of comparable quality, subject to applicable requirements, so your insurer may authorize aftermarket or recycled parts unless your policy provides special coverage for OEM replacements.
This doesn't automatically mean an aftermarket part is inferior, but some repairs require particular components or procedures to ensure that the vehicle's safety systems operate properly. Some automobile insurers offer optional OEM parts coverage, although eligibility and limitations vary. It's worth asking about this protection when shopping for insurance, especially if you drive a newer vehicle equipped with advanced safety features.
Windshields offer a good example of how much vehicle repairs have changed. On many newer cars, cameras mounted near the windshield support automatic emergency braking, lane-keeping assistance, and other driver-assistance features. Replacing the glass may require recalibrating these systems, even when the windshield itself has been installed correctly.
Virginia addressed this issue with its Motor Vehicle Glass Act, enacted in 2026. The law requires glass repair businesses to inform customers whether their vehicles have advanced driver-assistance systems, whether the manufacturer recommends recalibration after windshield work, and whether the shop intends to perform it according to manufacturer specifications.
If the shop cannot perform the necessary calibration, it must advise the customer to visit a qualified specialist or manufacturer-certified dealership. Businesses that perform calibration must also provide written notice of whether it was successful. Although the law doesn't automatically require insurers to pay for original manufacturer glass or dealership repairs, it helps drivers understand whether important safety procedures are being addressed.
What happens when the two sides can't agree?
If the insurance company and body shop reach an impasse, you may be responsible for some of the additional expense, depending on your policy and the reason for the disagreement. Before agreeing to pay anything beyond your deductible, ask the shop for an itemized explanation of the charges the insurer hasn't approved. The difference may involve labor rates, replacement parts, hidden damage, or a particular repair procedure. Your insurance adjuster should also be able to explain why those charges weren't approved and whether additional documentation or another inspection might resolve the issue.
It's important to understand your financial responsibility before authorizing work, particularly if the shop intends to proceed with repairs the insurer hasn't approved. Ask about any additional charges you may owe, including storage or diagnostic fees that might accumulate while the disagreement is being resolved. Virginia's Automobile Repair Facilities Act provides another safeguard: when you request a written repair estimate, a shop generally cannot charge more than 10% above that estimate without your authorization for the additional work, although different rules apply to certain older vehicles.
If you believe your insurer isn't handling the claim properly, you can ask to have the matter reviewed by a claims supervisor. For unresolved concerns, the Virginia State Corporation Commission's Bureau of Insurance accepts consumer complaints and can review whether an insurer has followed state law and its policy obligations. Keeping copies of repair estimates, photographs, correspondence, and any manufacturer repair instructions supporting the disputed work will make it easier to explain your concerns.
Most drivers don't give much thought to how their automobile insurance handles repairs until they need to file a claim. Yet the details matter, particularly when a vehicle has expensive technology or requires specialized parts. Before repairs begin, ask how additional damage will be handled, whether the insurer and repair shop have agreed on the proposed work, and what expenses you might be responsible for.
A higher repair estimate doesn't necessarily mean there's a problem, and a disagreement doesn't automatically mean you'll have to pay the difference. Understanding what each party is proposing, and why, puts you in a better position to get your vehicle repaired properly without an unwelcome surprise when it's time to pick it up.
Read more from our sources:
Comments